Today’s launch of the Milburn Review’s final report seems to have been a long time in coming (though, by government standards, it’s actually been quite an efficient process). However, Alan Milburn’s time spent deliberating is to be welcomed. The problems faced by young people Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEETs) are deep-rooted and longstanding. Resolving the issue demands proper consideration and well-thought-out solutions. To that end, the Milburn Review is to be welcomed. That said, CAP feels that there is also reason to receive some of the recommendations with caution.
First, the positives. Milburn has clearly been prepared to be bold — which is one of our core values at CAP. His imaginative examination of the NEETs issue has seen him take a “What Works” approach to identifying possible solutions. He has drawn on examples from other countries, including The Netherlands and Denmark, to find what can be done when a whole generation faces concerns about finding work. Many of his proposals focus on how we can move more 18–25 year olds away from welfare and into work. Again, this is something that CAP also advocates for. Indeed, our Job Clubs (run in partnership with the DWP) are focused on moving people into well-paying and high-quality employment — recognising that this is the best route out of cyclical poverty. Another of our core values is compassion, and we recognise that a life on welfare for those who are able to work is neither sustainable nor compassionate given the potential personal growth that can result from work.
It is also refreshing to see someone approach NEETs as an “early years to 25” issue. Whilst the definition of NEET is rooted in the age range of 18–25, it is clear that many of the factors contributing to later employment problems begin during early years development. For instance, recent research from Dr Luke Munford at The University of Manchester has found that you are three times more likely to become NEET if you begin primary school still in nappies. Likewise, high-quality and prioritised employability advice in schools, colleges and universities (accompanied by a diversity of options ranging from a pre-apprenticeship through to degree-based training) can provide confidence for those entering the workforce.
Milburn’s thinking around Employers’ National Insurance is another welcome attempt to open up conversations around innovative policy solutions. It could make it easier for employers to hire many of those currently seeking work and unable to find openings. Recent Office for National Statistics (ONS) data found that there were 22,000 fewer-than-expected vacancies in the economy last quarter. Such pressures only compound the socio-economic problems faced by jobseekers. However, the NI cuts proposed are likely to focus on the hospitality and retail sectors. Traditionally, many younger workers find jobs in those sectors, so it makes sense that they should benefit. The issue, though, is one of job quality. Many jobs in the hospitality and retail sectors are low hours, low-pay and temporary. Incentivisation of job creation is clearly part of the solution to the NEETs crisis but it must not come at the expense of quality and affordability for the person seeking employment.
There are also reasons to be cautious, however. The idea that existing claimants could be moved onto the new scheme in such a way as to reduce their benefits is concerning. We’re yet to see the full detail on this but should remember that many of those out of work already experience high levels of anxiety about what the future may hold for them, given their lack of income. It is right that Milburn felt able to make these kinds of bold suggestions, in order to ensure that his review was genuinely open and comprehensive, but the impetus is now on the government to urgently offer reassurance to those who may be affected by the pending changes. Waiting until the New Year White Paper on Milburn’s recommendations would not be fair, as it would leave too many people worrying about what the new measures mean for them at precisely the point that they head into the winter with rising energy bills on the horizon.
Moreover, we should avoid the narrative of ‘benefit cuts’ taking over how the review is discussed and implemented. Milburn has correctly said that he opposes the principle of ‘crude cuts’ to benefits, given that these often push people into other areas of the welfare system (with a related heavy cost to the taxpayer). We should also remember that 40% of those currently classified as NEET do not receive a form of welfare payment. Thus, to lose genuine discussion of imaginative solutions to the NEET crisis in a blunt “welfare versus cuts” narrative would be to miss exactly the ‘once in a generation’ opportunity with which Milburn is encouraging ministers to engage.
CAP Group CEO, Stewart McCulloch commented:
Fear and worry are not a good basis upon which to seek work and, whilst we recognise that the Milburn Review does not intend to cause such concerns, we need to see the government prioritise addressing these aspects in its response next month.
Overall, we are happy to greet the Milburn Review as a sign of serious engagement with the problem of youth economic inactivity. Since data on this problem was first collected in 2001, the NEET rate has never fallen below 9%. That’s not sustainable or economically-sound for any modern society. Many of the review’s ideas are innovative, bold and compassionate — exactly the kind of approach we advocate for at CAP. Nevertheless, this moment of reform carries with it certain dangers. As an organisation, CAP is able to wait until the White Paper is published in the New Year. Those we serve, however, cannot wait that long. They need certainty, reassurance and help. The Government must now provide these, and urgently.